Using Protocol Relative URLs to Switch between HTTP and HTTPS

February 02th, 2010 - 1:55PM

Attempting to use HTTP resources on an secure web page is a guaranteed way to annoy IE users, because it generates a confusing security warning for anyone running with the default IE settings. Our previous post on fixing this message in IE 8 is responsible for more than 50% of the traffic and comments on this blog. Hopefully, Microsoft will take note and change this in a future version of IE.

In the meantime, it’s important to avoid this warning by ensuring that every image, CSS and Javscript file on a secure page is accessed using HTTPS. For content on the same domain it’s quite straightforward – you just need to use relative URLs. A relative URL contains the ‘offset’ URL that needs to be applied to the page’s absolute URL in order to find a resource.

For example, here’s a screen shot from HttpWatch accessing our home page over HTTPS:

Searching for one of the images in HttpWatch shows that it was specified with a relative URL and the switch to HTTPS happened automatically:

A problem arises though, if you attempt to access a resource from a different domain because you can’t use the simple path-relative URL to access the resource. This often happens when you attempt to use a third party service such as Google Analytics or a third party Ajax library CDN.

Google Analytics solves the problem with its external javascript file by recommending the use of this code to dynamically switch protocols:

var gaJsHost = (("https:" == document.location.protocol) ?
    "https://ssl." : "http://www.");
document.write(unescape("%3Cscript src='" + gaJsHost +
    "google-analytics.com/ga.js' type='text/javascript'%3E%3C/script%3E"));

Another solution is to hard code the external resource with an HTTPS based URL regardless of how the containing page is accessed. This avoids any security warnings in IE, but does mean that the HTTPS resource download will consume more CPU resources in cases where the HTTP download would have been sufficient.

The solution we prefer to use is to specify a Protocol Relative URL. It’s just like a regular URL except that you leave out the protocol prefix. For example, when Microsoft recently announced SSL support for their Ajax CDN the recommended script tag for secure pages was:

<script src=”https://ajax.microsoft.com/ajax/jquery/jquery-1.3.2.min.js” type=”text/javascript”></script>

But if you change this to a protocol relative URL:

<script src=”//ajax.microsoft.com/ajax/jquery/jquery-1.3.2.min.js” type=”text/javascript”></script>

You get the automatic use of HTTPS on secure pages and avoid the overhead of HTTPS on non-secure pages.

We put together a simple jQuery demo page using this technique. In HttpWatch, you can see that the resource is automatically downloaded with HTTP for non-secure access:

and HTTPS with secure access:

One downside of this approach is that there will be separate cached copies for both the HTTP and HTTPS based URLs. If a vistor to your site first uses a non-secure HTTP based URL and then switches to HTTPS they would have to download fresh copies of resources that had already been accessed over HTTP.

UPDATE: Steve Souders pointed out another downside to using protocol relative URLs; they cause a double download of CSS files in IE 7 & 8.

Even more problems with the IE 8 mixed content warning

September 09th, 2009 - 6:03PM

We have previously written about the pointless and confusing ‘Do you want to view only the webpage content that was delivered securely‘ message in IE 8. It is displayed by default when a secure web page attempts to use non-secure content such as images, javascript or CSS. That post has been so popular that it attracts 40% of the traffic to this blog.

The IE 8 mixed content dialog is pointless because 99.9% of web users just want it to go away and let them get on with what they were doing. For the 0.1% of web surfers who do care, it is confusing because of the way it is worded:

The blog post described how you can disable this warning and from the comments it looks like many users are now doing this.

Even if you do this, IE still silently performs the check and hides the re-assuring padlock icon that you normally see on HTTPS pages:

This could be disturbing for anyone on a checkout page who is about to enter their credit card details. So if you’re web site developer you really need to avoid using mixed content – even for users who have disabled this warning. Firefox has the mixed content warning turned off by default. Let’s hope Microsoft do the same turn in the next version of IE.

You can normally fix the mixed content warning by ensuring that all the content on a secure page is served up with HTTPS. In HttpWatch you can quickly check a page by using a forced refresh to look for URLs starting with ‘http;’ :

However, a customer contacted us recently because they were still getting the mixed content warning even though they had no HTTP URLs on their secure page. After some investigation it was found that this commonly used javascript technique was causing the problem:

// Causes mixed content message in IE on a secure page
document.write("<script id="__ie_onload" src="javascript:void(0)"></script>");
document.getElementById("__ie_onload").onreadystatechange = function()
{
     if (this.readyState == "complete") domReady();
};

It’s a trick used to emulate a DOMContentLoaded event in IE.  A security warning occurs because of the use the “javascript:” protocol even though no download occurs.

The fix is to use //: in the src attribute in the same way as popular javascript libraries such as jQuery and prototype. This does cause a harmless ERROR_INVALID_URL entry in HttpWatch, but it avoids the mixed content message:

// Does not cause a mixed content message in IE on a secure page
document.write("<script id="__ie_onload" src="//:"></script>");
document.getElementById("__ie_onload").onreadystatechange = function()
{
     if (this.readyState == "complete") domReady();
};

Fixing the IE 8 warning – ‘Do you want to view only the webpage content that was delivered securely?’

April 04rd, 2009 - 11:39AM

In a previous blog post, we talked about the problem of using HTTP based resources, such as images, on a secure HTTPS page. Internet Explorer interrupts the download and displays a confirmation dialog whenever it detects the use of mixed content on a secure page.

In IE 7 and ealier, this dialog would cause annoyance to users but generally didn’t cause any other significant problems. This was because it was worded in such a way that most users would click on the Yes button and allow non-secure content to be downloaded.

However, the wording in the IE 8 version of this dialog has changed:

To download the content a user would now have to click on the No button. As we know, most people using the web only scan text and avoid reading it if at all possible! They will usually go for the Yes button if there is not an OK button.

Some sites are going to find that their secure pages in IE 8 have the following problems:

• Any non-secure HTTP image beacons used for analytics data gathering will often be ignored
• The page may not display or even work correctly if it relies on non-secure images, CSS or Javascript

Therefore, avoiding mixed content on HTTPS pages is even more important now that IE 8 has been released. It often becomes an issue when using third party services such as analytics or Content Delivery Networks (CDN). For example, we avoided the use of Google hosted Ajax libraries on our site until Google added HTTPS support.

As mention in the previous blog post, an IE user you can disable this warning by:

1. Going  to Tools->Internet Options->Security
2. Select the ‘Security’ tab
3. Click the ‘Custom Level’ button
4. In the ‘Miscellaneous’ section change “Display mixed content” to Enable

However, if you are developing a web site you can’t expect your visitors to do this. It is better to fix the cause of the problem so that the warning is not displayed by default in IE 8. The only way to do this warning is to ensure that your HTTPS pages only access embedded resources using the HTTPS protocol. You can do this by following these steps:

1. Use a sniffer like HttpWatch that supports HTTPS and shows files being read from the browser cache. The free Basic Edition is sufficient for this because you only need to see the URLs being accessed.
2. Access the page causing the problem and click No when you see the security warning dialog.
3. Any HTTP resources shown  in the HttpWatch window are the source of the problem; even if they loaded directly from the browser cache and didn’t cause a network round trip:
4. If you don’t initially see any HTTP based resources, try refreshing the page because a non-secure image may have been retrieved from the IE or Firefox image cache

EDIT: If you are a web developer trying to track down why your page causes this warning please also take a look  at http://blog.httpwatch.com/2009/09/17/even-more-problems-with-the-ie-8-mixed-content-warning/ where we cover some javascript snippets that can also trigger this warning. The comments section of both of these posts also contain useful information where people have found and solved related issues.